#1 Mary Pickford: 39%
#2 Lillian Gish: 36%
#3 Gloria Swanson: 18%
#4 Norma Talmadge: 3%
It was a tight race with Lillian and Mary tied to about the last few days. On the last day Mary won by ONE vote. Norma didn't get much love, only 2 votes. Personally my own choices are hard to pick...mainly because shockingly I think GLORIA is the one who gave Mary a run for her money. These are my picks:

#1: Mary Pickford
Mary just never ever gets her due. Everyone thinks she was Shirley Temple and had no range beyond little girls. I disagree. Her range was there, though I think she did get static in it with time (and thus the horror that is Kiki occurred). However a great actress is usually judged by her dead baby scenes (the over dramatic sentimental goop) and Mary just excelled at those.
However bits of comedic timing are there too. Little Annie Rooney, My Best Girl, and so forth. Mary was a great actress, with a wonderfully expressive face for silents. For the die hard Gish fans, and even my own Swanson opinion, there is particularly one good reason Mary should be declare 'the greatest silent film actress'...because though she did act and act well in talkies (Secrets for example) she barely made any. By and large she was the greatest silent film actress ever.

#2: Gloria Swanson
I think had I put Louise in there I'd put her just below Gloria. Its very odd to me that many do not recognize Gloria Swanson as one of the acting greats. Her DeMille films (like most DeMille films) were absurd and silly, but her acting in them was enjoyable (especially opposite Thomas Meighan). As the 20s passed by her acting grew more and more wonderful, her performances to me always seem quite real, very sincere. I cant recall a Swanson dead baby moment, but I almost wonder if I am just forgetting something...surely she tried to outdo Mary at least once that way!
She said she hated comedy (and could not see the genius in his lord and savior Charlie Chaplin...praise be his name) but she could be wonderfully funny when she wanted to...usually with DeMille. I particularly love "Why Change Your Wife?" with Gloria pretending to be a stuffy old housewife who all of a sudden becomes glamorous and ends up in a catfight after husband swapping. Seriously the words "Gloria Swanson and Bebe Daniels catfight" just makes life worth living. Mary's catfights were usually little girl pulling hair affairs...Gloria was throwing vases!
Gloria reached her greatness at the end of the 20s once she had not only become independent (United Artists), but found someone to be her partner in crime as well (Walsh, then Kennedy). Her performance in Sadie Thompson gives me chills its so wonderful. You should have heard my audible yell when it abruptly ended (I hadn't read the case before watching it, the last reel is missing). The way she goes from jazz baby to deeply frightened and disturbed Christian is just...perfection. That performance alone almost makes me put her above Mary.
THAT being said most of Gloria's greatness was in her varied talkies. Sunset Blvd is right up there with Sadie Thompson. Seeing that loony ending scene on the big screen is just as chilling as the end of Sadie. I've heard a few complaints saying she overacted in that film, but I think the majority of people would agree its one of the best films ever. Gloria was just fantastic...I think more people need to realize that.

#3 Louise Brooks
What the hell I'm putting her in here though I forgot her in the original poll. Louise was stunningly gorgeous like Greta Garbo, however she just excelled in silents. Not only that but much like the other ladies on this list she fought hard for good roles and was quite an intelligent woman. She really didn't do much comedy, but I don't think she would have been out of place in one (The Old Army Game comes to mind).
Louise was one of those rare flapper/vamps where she was doing some seriously heavy acting, and after awhile wasn't even the character purposely causing the trouble (thus giving her more range to act). She even had the equivalent of a dead baby scene in Diary of a Lost Girl! I think she was a wonderfully serious actress, and praise of her much like Mary and Swanson will never be enough.

#''4'' Lillian Gish
Mr. Griffith must be mad at me right now. I love Lillian in my own way...she will always be 'goat eyes' to me. She was a good actress, and wonderfully beautiful if filmed right. She made her last film in her 90s and still was wonderful. However that right there slightly bumps her down the list: Lillian acted from flickers to 1989 which means some of her best pieces aren't silents.
I'm about to commit hearsay here but I think she's overrated. She lived long enough to guarantee she would receive acclaim (bless her soul I'd do the same thing) and her name is synonymous with a great serious dramatic actress. I think those who say she never quit acting (her personal life seemed just as guarded) were dead on. She wanted to be a serious actress and she was. She'd play all the dead baby and waify roles until the title was hers!
I'm not even fully sure she's my favorite Griffith actress. Miriam Cooper was a lot more fun. Hearsay aside, I do enjoy her work especially "Way Down East" which was fun (and had a dead baby and even a life risking scene in the river!) I just don't think she was the best actress, let alone best silent actress. Send your hate mails...I stand by it!

#''5'': Norma Talmadge
When I did the Silent Comedian poll I knew I was missing out on Fatty Arbuckle, he was alongside Raymond Griffith a choice I was not very familiar with. A friend gave me a copy of some Buster and Fatty shorts and I just loved him! Honestly I'd probably put him ahead of Lloyd...and pending further viewing MAYBE even Buster (who learned a great deal from him).
I mention this now because despite my best journalistic intentions I have not seen a Norma film, even though I wanted to before the poll was up. During the 10s and 20s the Talmadges were seen as a great acting family: Norma on drama, Constance on comedy, and Natalie on making Buster Keaton go crazy. Now they are mostly forgotten, heck they barely made it to the end of the silents! But much like Mary, Norma would be an almost complete silent star, she only made 2 talkies (half of Mary's output).
One thing to give consideration to is Mary remade 2 of her films for talkies: Kiki, and Secrets. I hear Norma's silent versions are fantastic, but have yet to see them. I am sure she was a competent actress, but I just do not know enough to rank her higher at this time.













