Continuing from yesterday here is the rest of Hollywood Babylon 2: Debunked.
Click here to read part 1. And to read the debunking of the
original Hollywood Babylon click here.
The Magic of Self MurderAhhhh Anger's favorite made up topic. This chapter is nothing but a bunch of 'so and so died this way'. Let’s debunk the hell out of it.
Charles Butterworth: Anger concedes his official cause of death is accident by Anger claims it was indeed 'suicide'. He doesn't elaborate and the official story is Butterworth lost control of his car on sunset (not a hard feat). He also died on June 13th, 1946 not June 14th as Anger says. Anger claims he killed himself over the loss of his friend Robert Benchley. Benchley died after a long illness November 21st, 1945. Anger says it was a 'few months' between their deaths. It had almost been a year...possible but unlikely. A car accident wouldn’t be an assured death, and it'd be quite a painful way to try and go...
John Bowers: Died on November 17th, 1926, not 15th as Anger says. He began his career in 1914, not 1916. Some sources say his wife divorced him in 32, others say they were still married when he died. He never started a failed flying school, and his troubles stemmed from his lack of work. He did drown himself.
Click here for more about John Bowers.
James Murray: Anger covered this in Hollywood Babylon 1.
We already talked about it.
James Whale: Was born in 1889 not 1896. Whale came to Hollywood in 1929, not 1930. Ironically Anger gets the rest of the long story right...something he rarely ever does. Good for him.
Barbara Bates: For starters Albert Dekker did not kill himself (Anger mentions this right off the bat). She actually made her debut in Strange Holiday, not Salome when she danced. She indeed suffered from depression and personal troubles but only one known instance of an attempted suicide is known, right after her husband was diagnosed with cancer. She survived. Since Anger mentions it Ray McDonald also didn't kill himself, he choked on his food (how
Lya De Putti!) However Anger is right, she succeeded in killing herself via carbon monoxide in 1969.
Claire Maynard: Was discovered at a party, not in a modeling shop. Stage work wasn't her downfall, it was her very very short movie career. Indeed she killed herself via gas. Supposedly it wasn't the first time.
Click here for more info on her.Ross Alexander: He already did this in Hollywood Babylon,
we already debunked it.
Herman Bing: I question him killing himself based on he’s more elusive than Robert Ames. That being said at the least he died on January 9th, 1947, not January 10th, 1948 as Anger claims.
James Cardwell: Shot himself on January 31st, 1954 not February 4, 1954. He was 32 not 33. And his reason was depression over a lack of television work (Anger doesn’t mention this).
Arthur Edmund Carew (aka Arthur Edmund Carewe): Was born in Turkey, not Armenia. He died on April 22nd, 1937, not April 23.
Lester Cuneo: His first film was Sons of the Northwood, not Graustark. He was also 44, not 37.
Karl Dane: THIS is the book that started all this bullshit. So fine I'll debunk it once more cuz I love Karl. He arrived in America before WW1 broke out in Europe and he did extra work before his German roles. He married Helen Benson in 1921 and retired from the screen...Anger doesn’t mention this just saying his 'career didn’t amount to much until 1925'. Well that’s what tends to happen when you retire! Also his German films had been very popular so...it’s not like he fizzled out. He did play 'Ramadan' in Son of the Sheik (fantastically at that) but 'shifty' really wouldn’t be the word.
Dane's accent wasn't too bad,
you can hear it here. It also wasn’t the reason behind his downfall...he'd been making talkies for 2 years before he lost his contract with MGM. Dane claimed to have a nervous breakdown and indeed had suffered health problems as well. During this time Dane & Arthur made shorts for Paramount and RKO plus embarked on a successful vaudeville tour. He wasn't a failure by any means. He did own a stake in a hot dog stand outside of MGM, but he wasn’t RUNNING it. Besides Anger leaves out the part about Dane lost his money in a failed mining deal.
On April 13th, 1934 Dane was robbed of all the money had had: $18. On the 14th indeed he shot himself. But Anger leaves ALL THAT OUT. AHHH!
For more information on Dane please click here.Tom Forman: Already covered.Jonathan Hale: Died February 28th, 1966 not March 2nd, 1966
Bobby Harron: Was hired as a bit player, not film cutter. He shot himself on September 5th, 1920, not September 1st. Anger leaves out the interesting part: that the original claim was he had bought the gun off a bum (not believing in just GIVING money), put it in his coat, and forgot about it. His boyhood preacher even attested that this was indeed the cause of death. Believe it or not the press ate it up till many decades later. He likely shot himself over either loosing Griffith's favor or his rumored battle with his sexuality. However it’s hard to say he was gay. In fact he dated Dorothy Gish and another suicide reason might be she had broken up with him for another man (who she would marry). Either way his life wasn’t looking so good at that point.
George Hill: Already covered.Wallace McCutcheon Jr: Anger leaves out the part about McCutcheon being gassed during WW1, which led to mental and health problems like poor Max Linder
George Reeves: Reeves actually yelled at his guest, but stayed down and enjoyed a drink with them instead of running upstairs and blowing his brains out as Anger says. The account Anger gives is one that has been oft repeated (but not factual) to the press. Indeed he went upstairs and shot himself, surprisingly Anger doesn’t mention the popular rumor that foul play was involved. However most people who have researched it reach the point that he indeed killed himself.
Click here for more about that.
Walter Slezak: Killed himself after suffering from a long illness, which Anger doesn’t mention.
Mary Wiggins: Killed herself on December 19, 1945, not December 10th.
Gig Young: He and his new wife were indeed found dead but Angers assertion that he had murdered his wife than himself in a suicide pact wasn’t right. Young did not plan the act and the reason for it was never clear. He had suffered from mental problems and was currently being administered LSD. Anger mentions none of this.
Albert Dekker: As said once already Dekker did not kill himself. He was born Albert Van Ecke, not Alvert Van Dekker. Anger is a bit insane...he says Dekker killed himself and everything that had happened to him he had done to himself. Dekker was found handcuffed, blinded, kneeling in the bathtub with a noose around his neck (that had been tied to the curtain rod). Anger only mentions bits of this and says he was hanging from the rod...which was slightly impossible. He had been dead at least 2 days (Anger doesn’t mention this) and surely it would have come undone by then. In addition to all this there were sexually explicit words scrawled in lipstick on his body. There were no signs of forced entry but camera equipment and money were missing. Anger doesn’t mention any of this.
The coroner theorized it was autoerotic asphyxiation gone wrong. If indeed he got himself in that bind he must have been very skilled at it! Either something was a foul, or it was likely an accident...not a suicide (though that would be a hell of a grand finale!)
Jenny Dolly: Jenny married Harry Fox in 1914, divorcing in 1921. Anger doesn’t mention this. Whether she really was with a Max Constant or Gordon Selfridge is unknown. However her car accident occurred in 1933 with a fiancé named Tony. If Selfridge had really offered her $10 million it would have had to have been long before this...the Great Depression was on you know. Anger says she was in a great depression and never got over it. In reality she married a Bernard Vinissky in 1935...I think she was over it. She was 49 when she killed herself, not 48.
Rosie Dolly: She married several times, Anger only mentions once. Interestingly enough he doesn’t mention how she tried to kill herself in 1962, but she failed and died of a heart attack in 1970.
Trent Lehman: He wasn’t addicted to cocaine, and he moved back to LA for a girlfriend. He worked odd jobs, contrary to what Anger says. He was robbed shortly before his death, something Anger doesn’t mention. His friend returned home at 2AM not 1:30AM.
Peg Entwistle: Was born in Wales, not London. The HollywoodLand sign was created by Woodruff and Shoults, not Mack Sennett. Whether she actually received an ironic offer to star in a play about suicide the day after she actually committed it is unknown. People cite it a lot with no proof.
Russell Gleason: Accidentally fell, didn't kill himself. Died on December 26th 1945, not the 25th.
Irene Gibbons: She was a bit actress in the 20s, Anger doesn't mention that. She was a fashion success before celebrities, and she began designing for films in 1933, not 1938.
Linda Christian: She divorced Tyrone Power in the 1956, so their marriage didn't end with his death in 1958 as Anger claims. Then Anger apparently sipped a little too much pink champagne as he turns the story into that of her DOG COMMITTING SUICIDE!!! Holy Christ...this man needs help.
Art Acord: Was born in Utah, not Oklahoma. His parents were both Mormon, not Ute. I sincerely doubt he killed Germans with his bare hands. Acord wasn't the only Western actor who didn't do talkies, William S. Hart didnt either. And indeed he poisoned himself, but he was suffering from hepatitis as well. Anger doesn't mention that.
Abigail Adams: She annulled her marriage to Lyle Talbot at age 20, not divorced at age 27 as Anger claims. Also they were barely married a few months which is odd that he didn't mention that. I'm not sure if she ingested the drugs Anger specifically mentions but she did OD on a mix of booze and pills.
Nick Adams: Likely accidentally OD'd, didn't kill himself.
Pier Angeli: Died on September 10th, 1971, not September 11th.
Lynne Baggett: She claimed to be trapped for 6 days under a sleeper bed, not 2. She did attempt suicide but called the operator for help before the pills kicked in. And indeed OD'd on sleeping pills, but Anger leaves out how she asked her nurse to stay away for 2 days because she 'needed her rest'.
Scotty Beckett: Poor kid. Anger leaves out the part about how on May 8th Scotty checked into a nursing home for injuries caused by a beating. He was found dead 2 days later. His death was ruled 'inconclusive' though sleeping pills were by his bedside. This seems like it could have gone either way...but its not for sure a suicide.
Clara Blandick: She went out for Palm Sunday Mass, not just to 'get her hair done'. Once she returned home she did her hair and dress, took some pills, spread a blanket over herself (Anger forgot that part), tied a plastic bag over her head, and died. She left a note explaining it was due to her severe pain and oncoming blindness. I'd call this more 'selected euthanasia' than suicide. She was 81 after all!
Dorothy Dandridge: Was born in 1922, not 1923. Her screen debut was a bit part in a 1935 Our Gang short, not the Marx Brothers (that was her second film). In 1959, not 1963, Dandridge discovered the people handling her finances had swindled her and she owed a huge amount of back taxes. No oil scheme involved. For 2 years she had barely any work, and suffered a nervous break down. Anger mentions none of this. She was 42, not 41 when she died. She died over an accidental overdose of Imipramine, a tricyclic antidepressant not sleeping pills. So nope not a suicide. Ugh Anger.
Alan Ladd: Suffered alcoholism and depression, which ran in his family. Anger doesn't mention that part. He was actually an extremely wealthy man up to the end of his life, another thing Anger doesn't mention. As for the suspected robbery incident I cant find anything on it.
Carole Landis: Anger fails to mention how she tried to kill herself in 1944 and 1946. When she finally succeeded Rex Harrison was the last to see her alive and the first to discover her body. As for a jewel box and clutched envelope with one pill left in it...those seem to be Angerisims. Interestingly enough Anger doesn't mention how her family thought Harrison had something to do with her death (beyond motivation) but could never prove it. To this day its still ruled suicide.
Marilyn Monroe: Accident people not suicide.
Ona Munson: Was suffering from ill health when she killed herself, Anger fails to mention it.
Gail Russell: Was found dead in her Brentwood apartment, not West Hollywood (Beverly Hills separates the two). However she didn't kill herself. She died of a heart attack brought on by her alcohol problems (ala
Lottie Pickford). She was also suffering malnutrition when she died. Anger mentions none of this.
George Sanders: Anger waves his fake sex pen by saying Sanders went to Argentina to work for a tobacco advertising company after he graduated. There Anger claims he frequented brothels. Sanders actually worked for an advertising agency in England where Greer Garson suggested he break into acting.
Jean Seberg: Iowans are crazy everyone knows it. I kinda like her though. She was found dead in August 1979 after missing for 11 days. Anger gets it wrong saying she was found on September 6th, 1979. Her death was considered suspicious, but she had been suffering from depression so it very well could have been a suicide.
Everett Sloane: Killed himself on August 6th, 1965 not July 11th, 1965.
Inger Stevens: Moved to NY with her father at age 9. She made her stage debut in NY after running away at age 16; not in a 'sleazy Kansas burlesque house'. Anger then claims she returned to NY making it pointless. She killed herself on April 30th, 1970; not May 1st. She did it with tedral, not sleeping pills. She was found dead, and the person who found her was not her girlfriend as Anger claims.
Lupe Velez: We already did this one.
Grant Withers: Was born in 1905, not 1904. He was found March 27th, 1959 not 28th. Anger also fails to mention he was suffering from health problems.
Paul McCullogh: Had suffered from severe depression and had a stay in a sanatorium. Anger mentions none of this. He then indeed went in for a shave but actually finished the shave, then slit his wrist and throat. Anger says he just came in and slit his throat nothing else.
Hollywood HospitalMarilyn Monroe: Indeed she did end up in the nuthouse...but Anger has it ass backwards as usual. After divorcing Arthur Miller she voluntarily entered Payne Whitney Psychiatric Clinic. However they held her against her will (for her own good) and she described the whole thing as a 'nightmare'. Joe Di Maggio had to help her and had her transferred to Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center where she remained for 3 weeks. The clinic name, the claim her mother was in the same nut house, and that no one saved Marilyn from the place are all wrong in Anger's version.
Rita Hayworth: This book was written 2 years before her death. Anger says she was in diapers and being spoon fed. While neither of those things were ever proven true she did indeed suffer from Alzheimer's (which he mentions). But still that's a pretty low blow.
George Zucco: Anger claims he went crazy and died in a mental house. Actually he was in a retirement home and died of pneumonia.
Hollywood DrugstoreBarbara LaMarr: Already done.Carmen Miranda: People have asked about the
'Carmen Miranda story in Hollywood Babylon 2'. There doesn't appear to be one. There are two pictures of her, one of her dancing with a harmless caption. The second one claims she hid cocaine in her plats. I again doubt that and to back up my doubt some of her shoes are on display at her museum...surely someone could find such a compartment?
Nita Naldi: There is a HELL of a bad picture of
Nita Naldi in this section. She didn't seem like the cocaine type but apparently vamps don't age well. Personally I think alcohol was more her problem at the end of her life. I think Miss Naldi may come back in zombie form just to smack Anger for that photo...poor dear.